If you're shopping around for dog waste removal in Bonney Lake or Buckley, Two Sisters Scoop is probably one of the first names you've come across. They've been around since 2023, they've built a solid local reputation, and they cover a wide area across Pierce County. That's all real. This page isn't here to throw shade at a neighbor — it's here to give you a straight comparison so you can make a good call for your yard and your wallet.
Here's what we know about both services, laid out side by side.
What Two Sisters Scoop Offers
Two Sisters Scoop is run by Nichole Lubic out of Buckley. She started the business in 2023 and has grown it to cover a wide service map including Buckley, Bonney Lake, Lake Tapps, Enumclaw, Orting, Sumner, Wilkeson, and more recently areas as far as Tacoma, Puyallup, Auburn, and Maple Valley.
Their pricing is per-visit rather than monthly flat rates. Based on their published pricing, the first cleanup costs $55 for one dog plus $10 per additional dog. Weekly service runs $22 per visit for the first dog plus $5 per additional dog. Bi-weekly is $27 for the first dog plus $5 per additional. Their site lists service for properties up to a quarter acre.
They offer weekly, bi-weekly, one-time, and seasonal cleanups, along with commercial, HOA, and pet waste station services. Nichole texts before arrival and confirms when the job is done. Reviews consistently praise her communication and thoroughness. With hundreds of reviews, she's clearly doing something right.
Worth knowing: Two Sisters Scoop's terms of service specify that if more than 21 days have passed since your last scoop, a first-time cleanup fee applies on top of regular pricing. They also have a late payment fee structure starting at $2 after 5 days unpaid, scaling up to $15 after 15 days. These aren't unusual terms, but they're worth reading before you sign up.
How the Two Services Compare
Both businesses are locally owned, both serve Bonney Lake and Buckley, and both will text you before and after a visit with gate photo confirmation. Those are the baseline expectations in this market at this point. Where things differ is in pricing structure, what's included by default, and a few service specifics.
| Feature | Dootyful Scoopers | Two Sisters Scoop |
|---|---|---|
| Serves Bonney Lake / Buckley | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Pricing structure | ✓ Flat monthly rate | Per-visit pricing |
| Yard size limits | ✓ None on standard residential lots | Listed for properties up to 1/4 acre |
| First-visit / initial cleanup fee | ✓ None | $55 + $10/dog, again if 21+ days lapse |
| Frequency options | ✓ 5 options (2x/week through monthly) | Weekly, bi-weekly, one-time, seasonal |
| Once-a-month plan available | ✓ Yes — from $49/mo | Not listed |
| Dooty Report (health observations) | ✓ Every visit, included | Informal — mentions noticing issues |
| Customer dashboard (history & trends) | ✓ Dooty Dashboard, PIN-protected, included | Not offered |
| Fecal sample retrieval | ✓ Free with 24hr notice | Not listed |
| Gate photo confirmation | ✓ Every visit | ✓ Yes |
| Front yard included | ✓ Yes — full property | Not specified |
| Cat litter box service | ✓ Plans from $39/mo | Not listed |
| Dog walking | ✓ Solo walks, plans from $99/mo | Not listed |
| Vacation check-ins | ✓ From $19/visit | Not listed |
| Yard deodorizer add-on | ✓ Yard Freshen enzyme treatment | Not listed |
| Payment handling | ✓ Square invoice — we never store your card | Not specified |
| No contracts | ✓ Month-to-month, cancel anytime | ✓ No contract listed |
Want every Bonney Lake option scored side by side, not just two? See our Best Poop Scooping Services in Bonney Lake guide →
Where Dootyful Scoopers Is a Better Fit
Both services are solid choices for Bonney Lake and Buckley. The question is less about quality and more about what structure works for you.
If you want predictable monthly billing
Two Sisters Scoop bills per visit, which means your monthly cost fluctuates depending on how many visits happen in a given month. Some months have five Tuesdays. Dootyful Scoopers charges a flat monthly rate regardless of how many visits fall in the billing period. If you prefer knowing exactly what you'll pay each month, flat-rate billing is the cleaner setup.
If your yard is bigger than a quarter acre
Two Sisters lists service for properties up to a quarter acre. Plenty of lots in Tehaleh, the Foothills, and around Lake Tapps run bigger than that. Dootyful Scoopers doesn't apply yard size tiers or caps to standard residential properties.
If you want a once-a-month option
Two Sisters' listed plans are weekly, bi-weekly, and one-time. If you're a single-dog household in a small yard and you'd rather have someone come by once a month for a lighter routine, Dootyful Scoopers offers a monthly plan starting at $49.
If you want a structured visit report
Nichole mentions she'll flag things she notices during a visit, which is genuinely caring and useful. Dootyful Scoopers formalizes that into a written Dooty Report sent after every visit — a consistent record of what was observed in your yard, including anything that might warrant a vet conversation. For households where health tracking matters, having that written record from visit to visit is worth something.
A structured report is worth having. A structured report you can still find eight months later is worth more.
Every report we send lands in your Dooty Dashboard, a private page behind your own PIN. Not a payment portal and not another login to manage. It fills in after your first visit and keeps building every time we come back, so instead of scrolling six months of texts you get one page with the whole history on it.
What gets tracked depends on why we were there. Each service logs the numbers that actually matter for that service, and all of it collects in the same place:
Poop pickup
- Visits and total scoops
- Pounds of waste removed
- Stool consistency, 1 to 5
- Green, yellow, or red health flag
- Gate photo per visit
Dog walking
- Walks completed
- Time on foot and distance
- Potty breaks logged en route
- Energy and behavior notes
- Photo from the route
Litter boxes
- Boxes serviced per visit
- Scoop count per box
- Deep cleans completed
- Litter added
- Output and consistency notes
Vacation check-ins
- Visits completed against your booking
- Food and water confirmed
- Medication doses given
- Arrival and departure times
- Locked-door photo per visit
If you use us for more than one thing, that is one login covering all of it. The walk your dog got Tuesday, the litter boxes we cleaned Wednesday, the yard we scooped Friday: one history, one set of trends, one place to click a date and pull up that day's report and photo.
Two Sisters is a good local outfit and we mean that. This is simply something we built and they have not. See how the Dooty Dashboard works →
If payment security matters to you
Dootyful Scoopers invoices through Square, which means we never see or store your card number. You manage your payment directly inside Square's platform. No new account to create, no card data sitting in anyone's spreadsheet.
More than the yard
Scooping is where we started, not where we stop. The same team also handles cat litter box cleaning (plans from $39/mo), solo dog walks (plans from $99/mo), and vacation check-ins for dogs, cats, and even chickens while you travel. Every one of those visits logs to the same Dooty Dashboard, and we'll pick up a fecal sample for your vet free with 24 hours notice.
Short version: Two Sisters Scoop is a well-run local business with strong reviews and solid community standing. If you're in their core Buckley or Enumclaw area, they're a proven option. If you're in Bonney Lake and want flat monthly pricing, no yard-size math, a formal health-aware visit report, and payment handled through Square, Dootyful Scoopers is built specifically for that.
Our Plans at a Glance
| Plan | Frequency | Monthly Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Dog — Twice a Week | Every 3 to 4 days | $149/mo |
| Dog — Once a Week | Every 7 days | $99/mo |
| Dog — Every Other Week | Every 14 days | $74/mo |
| Dog — Twice a Month | 2 visits per month | $69/mo |
| Dog — Once a Month | Once per month | $49/mo |
| One-Time Pickup | One-time service | $79 |
All plans are month-to-month. Pause, switch frequencies, or cancel anytime directly from your invoice link — no call required, no fee, no awkward conversation.
Plans start at just $49/mo
No first-visit or initial cleanup fee
Locally owned in Bonney Lake, WA
Ready to Give It a Try?
We serve Bonney Lake, Buckley, Sumner, Lake Tapps, Tehaleh, and surrounding Pierce County areas. If you've been comparing services and you like what you see here, getting started is straightforward.
Fill out the quick form on our homepage with your address, dog count, and which plan you're interested in. We'll confirm your spot, schedule your first visit, and text you when we're on our way. After the visit, you'll get a gate photo and your first Dooty Report. No first-visit fee. No yard-size math. No new account to create.
Just a clean yard from someone who actually gives a dooty.
Gate Photo Every Visit
We confirm every service with a photo so you always know your yard is clean and your gate is latched.
Dooty Report
A written visit summary with health observations after every single service — not just a "we came" receipt.
Flat Monthly Rate
One price per month, every month. No per-visit billing, no month-to-month fluctuations.
Full Property, One Price
Front, back, and side yards covered. No yard-size tiers on standard residential properties.
No Contracts
Month-to-month service. Cancel or adjust anytime from your invoice link.
Based in Bonney Lake
We're your neighbors — not a call center, not a franchise. When you message us, you're talking to us.
Dooty Dashboard
Every visit from every service, charted over time behind your own PIN. Included with all plans.
Free Fecal Sample Pickup
Vet asked for a sample? Give us 24 hours notice and we'll bag it for you at no charge.
More Than the Yard
Litter boxes, dog walks, and vacation check-ins from the same local team, all on one dashboard.
Sources
Competitor details on this page come from each company's own website (checked October 2026) unless noted. Services change their pricing and policies; if something here is out of date, let us know and we'll correct it.
- Two Sisters Scoop: service pricing (2sistersscoop.com)
- Two Sisters Scoop: terms of service (21-day first-cleanup rule, late fees)
- Dootyful Scoopers plans and pricing: dootyfulscoopers.com